I watched this movie day before yesterday and really liked it. It’s such a plain and simple story but refreshing indeed. kareena is awesome… looked beautiful and acted superbly too… Dialogs & incidents are taken from our daily life only… Simple yet stylish and beautiful.

We say ‘life is a journey’.. well this movie tells us more precisely that it’s a train journey.

After JWM, I am lookng for Imtiaz’s previous movie ‘Socha Na Tha’. My friends who have watched that movie, told me that that’s also a nice movie. There the male character was confused in love, and here the female lead is, in JWM.

Atlast but not the least, Imtiaz is from my place i.e Jamshedpur.

Anywaz on a more serious note, Kareena does appear a bit loud but then that’s what her role demands. So you can’t really blame her, on the whole she has done a good job.

Jasleen – Thanks.

I completely agree with your review. I was slightly apprehensive of Kareena being able to carry an effervescent “Sikhni’s” role but she did a great job. I can’t think of anyone from the younger lot to have been able to do it as much justice. I had liked them together in Chupke Chupke as well. Its too bad that they broke up in real life but that has nothing to do with the film (& none of my business).

Shahid was excellent as well. He seemed to get better as teh film progressed but Kareena just knew what was going on! Her expressions, her timing, and all the other technical stuff – seemed just fine and good enough for me to recommend someone else to devote 2 1/2 hours of their life to this piece of entertainment.

Naresh – Yup, thats the joke doing rounds.

Anu – Thanks re.

Meenakshi – Really? You hated it so much? I get a feeling you ain’t a Kareena fan.

Gaurav – Yes, you should.