Post

Manu Sharma’s Murder Confession

Since the beginning of the Jessica Lall retrial, the media section across the nation have contributed in bringing together many hidden facts and countless loopholes in the Indian judiciary system and make it public.

A gruesome but straightforward murder case of Jessica Lall, was twisted & molded by the people in authority and the accused, all of this simply setting an example that in our country “Money talks and Killers walk-off”.

And here is yet another proof of our judiciary corruption.

India’s leading news channel NDTV was able to go thru the content of an audio CD in which Manu Sharma’s confession of shooting Jessica Lall is claimed to have been recorded. The confession was recorded by Delhi Police, seven days after the murder when Manu Sharma had surrendered.

The content has been published on NDTV website.

Police: Did you know Malini Ramani before?

Manu: No, sir. There was Jessica Lall, I did not know her name.

I was told even if you give a thousand bucks, I will not give a sip of wine and I said that we have got an arrangement there. I pulled out my pistol there.

Police: How much did you pay for this (gun)?

Manu: Sir, I have a license from Chandigarh and bought it from Ambala for about Rs 16,000 and I fired one shot in the air.

Police: Air?

Manu: Yes, that is inside the Colonade. So it went into the roof and nobody bothered, nobody moved. Then I pointed at Jessica and what I intended to do was I pointed slightly away from her so that I could see her hair, I wanted to generally shoot.

Police: What was the idea?

Manu: The idea at that time was to shoot in challenge. It was embarrassing to hear that even if I paid a thousand bucks I would not get a sip of drink.

I pointed towards her a little and fired the shot.

However, the Inspector incharge of the case did not consider the audio CD as a crucial piece of evidence and therefore never presented it in the court during the first trial.

The Delhi Police tried to cover-up this lapse in investigation by stating that the CD could not be taken as evidence since the confession was recorded without the presence of a magistrate, which is needed to prove its authencity in the court. However many lawyers have an opinion that the CD should have been presented in the court and the decision of its validity as an evidence should have been left of the judges to decide.

One may even argue that maybe the CD was made by the officials in-charge of the case, inorder to be used for blackmailing and thereby extorting money from the accused. And therefore the recorded confession in the absence of a magistrate was never meant to be used as evidence.

But now that the audio CD has made its way to the media and its contents have been disclosed, it has surely put an additional pressure on the Delhi Police to prove its capability and do whatever it takes to put the accused Manu Sharma behind bars for his horrendous crime.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks

Trackback Address »

[...] Jessica Lall’s murder was shocking and painful just like Priyadarshini Mattoo rape and murder, just like Manjunathan’s brutal death and god only knows how many more that are today just part of India’s shinning statistics. But the corruption syndrome is so deeply gutted in our lives, in our system that it not only bends the prescribed law but so darn earn easily moulds it to ones convenience and desired outcome. [...]

Pingback by To Each Its Own » Archives » Ram Jethmalani’s Bastardly Act — November 5, 2006 at 11:54 am | #

[...] Jessica Lall’s murder was shocking and painful just like Priyadarshini Mattoo rape and murder, just like Manjunathan’s brutal death and god only knows how many more that are today just part of India’s shinning statistics. But the corruption syndrome is so deeply rooted in our lives, in our system that it not only bends the prescribed law but so darn easily moulds it to one’s convenience and desired outcome. We cry out when certain laws are formed, others conveniently jump up and start blaming the laws and its procedures. But how can prescribed laws take course when the ones given to duty to carry it forward and implement it in a rightful manner; get busy abusing it and start taking it as some sort of a money-printing dhanda or odd publicity. [...]

Pingback by To Each Its Own » Archives » Ram Jethmalani’s Bastardly Act — November 6, 2006 at 2:02 pm | #

Comments

10 comments | Add your comment »

shadows
Oct 3rd, 2006 at 9:35 am | #

Sad.. for the state of Indian law mechanism.

On another note –
Moral of the story – Try as much as possible – to not be rude.

I am not downplaying the seriousness of the situation, but I wonder what was the need for Jessical Lall to talk like that, to anyone? I dunno if Manu started the “being rude” thing.

shadows
Oct 3rd, 2006 at 9:40 am | #

Dont the page 3 types have a much higher tendency to be rude and haughty. Just an observation, going by what I have seen on TV (not the page 3 movie), and personal observation at pubs.
No, I am not saying that rich ppl have that tendency, I am talking about page 3 types.

Saakshi O. Juneja
Oct 3rd, 2006 at 9:59 am | #

Shadows – I understand what you mean but the actual facts we shall never know. Maybe she was not rude but stern which aggravated Manu’s egostic nature.

Its kinda scary to see that in today’s world even a slight refusal doesnot go down with many and they resort to most horrible acts. I mean there have been many cases where young men have splashed Acid on girl’s who refused their marriage or sexual intentions.

Being rude is not limited to the Page 3 section…even a Police Officer at a minimal post tries to throw his weight onto those he can afford to.

shadows
Oct 3rd, 2006 at 11:48 am | #

Being rude is not limited to the Page 3 section…even a Police Officer at a minimal post tries to throw his weight onto those he can afford to.

Acknowledged as widely pervasive truth. :) Police wala he is, and he will do it. But strangely, page3 ppl are supposed to be the elite, supposedly intellectual, supposedly better behaved, but definitely many of them are not.

“Its kinda scary to see that in today’s world even a slight refusal doesnot go down with many and they resort to most horrible acts.”

Yeah, does not justify murder.

Saakshi O. Juneja
Oct 3rd, 2006 at 11:52 am | #

Shadows – Well the Police force is there to maintain so called Law and Order and preaching civilised behaviour but sadly (some) they are the ones taking the maximum advantage.

As for murder…well nothing could ever justify it. Atleast in most cases.

Ranajith Kumar
Oct 4th, 2006 at 2:38 am | #

The audio CD cannot be used in court becuase Manu Sharma’s lawyer was not present when the confession was made. Manu Sharma might say he was forced to confess becuase the police used torture methods to interrogate him.

Swapna
Oct 4th, 2006 at 9:46 pm | #

We don’t know the situation under which Jessica spoke the way she did. Nothing justifies what he did. Is fear of being killed a reason for which we need to stop being rude? (not that we should be rude in any situation)

I do think that the tape even though is now out, will get Jessica justice.

Mehak Malhotra
Nov 16th, 2006 at 7:17 am | #

Please give me your view/opinion/comments.

Do you feel that Jessica Lall’s case is going to fall victim to the wits of a lawyer’s arguments? Please give me your opinion: (yes/no) by clicking on the link below.

Yes – if you think the case is emerging to be a battle of wits and confrontational skills of a lawyer.
No – if you think the defense lawyer is doing his job judiciously in order to arrive at the truth of the case.

http://www.indiademocracy.com/issue/user/issue.jsp?issueid=iss20061111160833

While many of us were looking at Jessica Lall’s case setting a new trend and faith in the judicial system; the recent arguments made by Mr.Jethmalani have narrowed the hope. What the future holds for this case, time would tell – will it be lost to maneuver and manipulation once again or eventually result in providing justice!!!

Mehak Malhotra

Leave a comment

Comment Guidelines:
You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

eIndia reserves the right to take down irrelevant and improper comments without any notice. Please use your common sense when posting comments.

Email addresses will never be published.

About

Sakshi Juneja

We all have a right to express our views. In many instances; it will be against ours and in some; with us. To hear them out is 'decency' but to let them get to you is 'weakness'. More info »

I also blog at DesiDabba and DesiCritics

Campaigns

There are a lot of things that are wrong in this world. If we do not raise our voices and try to bring justice to these issues at hand, we do ourselves and our society an injustice. Here are some campaingns that are on-going at To Each It's Own

More campaigns

Recently on TEIO

Recent comments

Movie Reviews

More movie reviews

From DesiDabba

  • No items

Visit DesiDabba

somerights20

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-ShareAlike 2.5 License

hit counter