Post

Like a Virgin….

Our society is fixated on maintaining youth, defying age along with the concept of being ‘perfect’. Thousands of Indians have promoted the crore plus business of anti-aging procedures and products. Over the past few years, cosmetic surgery almost tripled.

In the past, plastic surgery had been substantially more popular for older women or for individuals suffering from illness where plastic surgery is required ; however, now, the number of men and younger women exploring their options in the world of plastic surgery has significantly increased. Although, the media does play a large role in our obsession with youth, it is not entirely to blame. Much of society feels that if they looked younger or prettier, then they would be more competitive in the workplace. There are many perceptions that the younger or prettier employee will get the promotion regardless of the experience or capabilities, since many people make up their ideas about a person based solely on his or her appearance. And this fact stands mostly true with our most popular Bollywood industry.

Though the plastic surgery procedure I am gonna highlight here, is not that well-known in India, but I seriously wonder how long will it take to reach our very own metro cities or maybe they do happen here on regular basis but like many other incidents are restricted behind closed door, due to the very nature of our society.

“It’s the ultimate gift for the man who has everything.” This is what Ms. Yarborough, a 40 year old medical assistant felt about her recent 17th anniversary gift – a surgery to reattach her hymen, making her appear a virgin again – to her husband. This controversial medical procedure, hymenoplasty, originally intended to protect females in the Middle East and Latin America, is gaining popularity in the U.S. for cosmetic reasons.

The procedure, also known as “revirgination”, is being hawked in magazines, the Internet or on radio stations as a way for women to improve their sex life or enjoy a second honeymoon. [Link]

The booming popularity of this procedure seems to reflect a wider trend of cosmetic surgery’s increased visibility and the western society’s increased acceptance of it.

Troy Robbin Hailparn, an obstetrician and gynecologist, advertises vaginal cosmetic surgery on 23 billboards around San Antonio. EdwardJacobson, a Greenwich, Conn., OB-GYN, offers international patients vaginal-makeover packages that include airfare, limousine travel and hotel accommodation.

“Revirgination” can cost over $5,000, but at Ridgewood Health and Beauty Center, a spa and cosmetic-surgery center in the New York City borough of Queens it costs as little as $1,800. Gynecologists are marketing hymenoplasty in magazines, local newspapers and online. They report business is booming.

However, not everyone is excited by such prospects. Many religious groups that value abstinence until marriage say hymen repair is a deception. Devout Roman Catholics consider sex before marriage sinful and equate female virginity with near divinity. For many Muslims, sexual purity, especially for women, is a way of maintaining the family’s sanctity.

Other criticisms of hymenoplasty include questions of the procedures legitimacy and safety. The ethics committee of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, concerned about the marketing of revirgination, has not taken a formal position on the matter, but has expressed concern over the lack of information in the medical literature regarding the procedure, a fact that may mean performers of the procedure are improperly trained. Many Gynecologic Surgeons consider hymen repair to be a totally bogus procedure. According to them, surgery marketed to improve one’s sex life rarely works. As for hymen replacement, “most importantly, it doesn’t make you a virgin again.”

Despite this fact, women are enticed by the ability to tighten their vaginal walls and even redesign the look of their private parts; participating women often indicate that such measures were meant to boost their own confidence levels or please their partners. According to some women, the reason they opted for this sort of plastic surgery because their husband wanted to experience intercourse with a virgin, explaining that “if a woman isn’t a virgin when she gets married, a man can always put her down for that.”

Tommorrow when hymen replacement surgery becomes popular in India, I doubt the reason for it would on ethical grounds. Being aware of our societal norms and culture, hymen repair is mostly likely to be just another expression of bigger social pressures that keep women submissive to men, a thought which has been expressed by feminist groups in US also. It would possibly be an extention to female genital mutilation, a procedure that often forces women to endure genitalia alterations, that modern and educated women now pay for. The self-deceptive double standards would yet again be visible through practices such as hymenoplasty — of the ‘bad’ woman intending to become the ‘good’ one.

The ethics involved in the debates surrounding plastic surgery cause conflicts in how people view the profession, as well as how people obtain and undergo these procedures. Plastic surgery can be seen in a positive light with regards to the positive outcomes experienced by many. This is by far the way it is seen by most of the population today, based on the large increase in procedures performed in recent years. By creating and uplifting a patient’s self-image, the ethical issues of plastic surgery can be put aside to focus on the positive outcomes.

However, these ethical issues have the potential to push the limits, and should constantly be evaluated with regards to the imminent threat they pose to the legitimacy and sustainability of the profession.

*Source : U.S. women seek a second first time with hymen surgery, By Amy Chozick, The Wall Street Journal.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks

Trackback Address »

[...] Revirgination anyone? In case you lost your hymen to horseriding, swimming, sex or if your hymen just got bored of staying there and decided to go for a walk – not all is lost! Sakshi on a surgery referred to as hymenoplasty. Ugh! [...]

Pingback by DesiPundit » Hymen For Sale — January 11, 2006 at 12:28 pm | #

Comments

17 comments | Add your comment »

neha
Jan 11th, 2006 at 12:29 pm | #

The concept of virginity is soooo strange na? I mean – for god’s sake the hymen and virginity have so little to do with each other!

aNTi
Jan 11th, 2006 at 4:01 pm | #

For the record, I am a guy. But I do find it strange that the effect of a hymen and the suitability of it as a tool for judgement is overrated. I am ashamed that a lot of guys I know value it way too high, much higher than it should be. From a scientific standpoint, there is scientific proof that strenous physical activities could lead to a ruptured hymen. So just because guys dont hit a barrier, the gal should not be shown in a bad light.
But the problem as I see it (at least from a Indian standpoint) is this. Gals in India get to know about the birds and bees, at least their part, relatively better (if not earlier) than a guy. Moms do take gals aside and tell them things. But for us guys, its porn. So while gals learn it from a biological point of view, for us guys it is mainly entertainment. Frankly, it was for me, when I was much younger. So I guess, we guys value the ends (the physical satisfaction, that is) a lot more than the means (i.e. the preceding non physical relationship)! Till we improve and introduce sex education and hence reduce the hymen to what it actually is, i.e., a thin membrane that has no function that *I* know of, the status quo is going to be maintained.

sakshi
Jan 11th, 2006 at 5:17 pm | #

Neha – I just couldn’t get over the bit that women go for it just to give that ‘virgin’ feeling to the partners. This just totally is disgusting. I mean the botton line is that the women is still NOT a virgin….even if she gets her hymen intacted. It’s just sad..that there are women out there who think this way.

shravan
Jan 11th, 2006 at 8:02 pm | #

So whats the problem?
If they want to give an enhanced feeling to their partners during sex, by making the partners believe that they are virgins, whats so shocking?
I mean, come on, face it, virginity is quite a turn on for a guy, and thats the way it is! Some guys like kinky stuff, some guys like to dress up, and some guys like virgins! We all have our little fetishes, and whats the problem with that??
Some guys would like a virgin more than a non virgin. I know girls who would like a guy who’s a virgin too.
Its just that guys don’t have a hymen which they can have implanted again. Or Im sure that would be happening too.
I mean come on guys, why is this so shocking?
Dear Sakshi and Neha, please wake up and smell the rubber (pun not intended).

sakshi
Jan 12th, 2006 at 5:26 am | #

Shravan – I won’t waste my time…pointing to every pathetic reason given by you. But would like to ask you one question, If your Girlfriend or Wife wants you to go in for a penis enlargement surgery…so that she gets better sexual staifaction..then would you go in for it ? Kindly do not take this the wrong way…I just wanted to make my point clear.

Amit Kulkarni
Jan 12th, 2006 at 12:38 pm | #

Why is a woman’s virginity so valued in the first place?

sakshi
Jan 12th, 2006 at 6:37 pm | #

Amit – Excatly my point. Whats so great about being a virgin or not? We are just puttin the pressure on ourself…for no real reason.

Ambuj Saxena
Jan 12th, 2006 at 7:51 pm | #

I have known that men in India value the ‘seal’ a lot, but I didn’t knew that even people in the west expected that. The difference being that pre-marital sex in India is a contraculture, while in the west it is counterculture. That they still expect virginity when its no longer ‘fashionable’ surprised me. Perhaps it has more to do with psychology that culture.

Shravan
Jan 14th, 2006 at 4:22 pm | #

Now thats totally irrelevant and personal. Also, you twist the argument. Now ur saying that the man is forcing the woman to re-hymen. Thats entirely a different story. If your guy asked you to do that, I would object Sakshi. However, if you decide to re-virginate yourself, by your own free will, then how is that anybody else’s problem? And why is it shocking? Think about it.

The argument is simple. Why do men value virginity, thats none of anybody’s business. But the fact is, they do. As Ambuj says, its a global phenomenon. Guys everywhere value virginity.

I guess since this is your blog, you’ll delete this comment. Oh well, atleast I tried.

Shravan
Jan 14th, 2006 at 4:42 pm | #

Just for the record.. penis enlargement surgeries are quite common.
I do not intend that you should agree with me.
Btw Im sorry if I hurt your belief’s in any way. I know. Truth hurts.
bye

HalfDesi
Jan 15th, 2006 at 5:38 am | #

The explicit purpose of hymen “repair” is to make intercourse painful for the woman.

This is quite different from a penis enlargement.

I am against the procedure.

More than that, I am against putting such a high value on female sexual purity in the first place. Especially when a similar value is not placed on male sexual purity.

If a man expects to marry a virgin, he should expect himself to be a virgin, too.

A man who is not a virgin, or who does not have any problems with his best buddies being “sexually impure”, has no right to hold his wife to a higher standard.

Amit Kulkarni
Jan 17th, 2006 at 11:13 am | #

Sakshi,

Like everyone probably knows, female virginity is valued everywhere. That should translate to looking for an answer in pre-history. It has been my thinking since the last couple of years that, due to pre-historic wars, men were killed a lot, leaving a lot of widows. This is probably the reason for legally having four wives in Islam. Societies were probably matrilineal in pre-history when it was not known for sure what exactly causes a pregnancy. I am guessing that when it was known for a fact that a sexual union starts the process of pregnancy, men probably started valuing virginity, to ensure that their progeny survived to the next generation. And that some other male did not impregnate their chosen woman. This primitive behaviour is repeated so many times today, when high profile celebrities become jealous when their girlfriend/boyfriend has sex with others.

My feeling is that society has been biased against women for so long, by allowing the practise of polygyny, that due to the changing demographics, the future will probably belong to something like polyandry. What is the root cause of wanting more sons? Because sons were expendable, in war. Now the tables have turned. Daughters should be more valued, as everything else, this concept will take a lot of time to filter to the people who don’t know about this.

Varun Singh
Feb 6th, 2006 at 9:29 am | #

There is nothing absolute right or wrong in this world. It depends upon perspective of the individual deciding the isue. Same thing applies to this Virginity debate. If some men like Virginity, its fine. Let them do that. If some women hate these kind of men, fair enough. They are free to do that. If some men dont have any issues about virginity, its great !!! And if some women like these free spirited guys, its good for them. If a woman wants to go in for hymenoplasty, let her do that, its her life and her body. If someone doesnt want, then its her decision.

The point is that let people decide these things on their own and noone can classify something as ABSOULTE RIGHT or ABSOLUTE WRONG. People in the context will decide that for themselves

satish
Feb 13th, 2006 at 11:30 am | #

Well, hymen or no hymen, virginity has its significance. What? Do I hear jeers of “stone aged guy”, a troglodyte or something. I will explain. I am a virgin guy, but I have been in a relationship.

Can anyone here ever ever forget his/her first love. The first time you fell in love. Can falling in love third or fourth time, beat the experience and thrill of falling in love the first time.

Replace love with sex above, and the situation is pretty much the same. Well, its not really rigid, but its preferable that both the gal and the guy be virgins for the relation to be successful. Or the guy might be thinking “my earlier gal was hotter” or the gal might be thinking “my earlier guy was better” , when both of them are in bed together.

Anilzone
Mar 9th, 2006 at 3:52 pm | #

hi
read all the views just now ( March 9 , ’06, 9 pm)

y gals and guys as well think ‘virginity’ or that ‘hymen’ is so important?

i guess, just a psychological gratification.

what if after that hymenoplasty , a gal gives her guy her ‘hymen’, and have sex with other guy/s afterwards?

its all in mind, i won’t mind if my wife possess that hymen or not, its she who is important to me, not that leaf.

love and the bond between a couple is supreme.

so lets forget all that crap regarding the revirginization and make space for love and trust.

anil. (28/m/delhi)
anilzone@hotmail.com

p.s. this is my first blog/blog response………..i’d appreciate your comments on my emailbox.

srijul p
Mar 21st, 2008 at 5:35 pm | #

Plz friend donot fight this follish topic.If i go the point of sakshi and Neha,it may be true.But there is not point to fight on this topic.Every humen have diffrent feeling.

Leave a comment

Comment Guidelines:
You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

eIndia reserves the right to take down irrelevant and improper comments without any notice. Please use your common sense when posting comments.

Email addresses will never be published.

About

Sakshi Juneja

We all have a right to express our views. In many instances; it will be against ours and in some; with us. To hear them out is 'decency' but to let them get to you is 'weakness'. More info »

I also blog at DesiDabba and DesiCritics

Campaigns

There are a lot of things that are wrong in this world. If we do not raise our voices and try to bring justice to these issues at hand, we do ourselves and our society an injustice. Here are some campaingns that are on-going at To Each It's Own

More campaigns

Recently on TEIO

Recent comments

Movie Reviews

More movie reviews

somerights20

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-ShareAlike 2.5 License

hit counter